Auqib Nabi's debut for India against the West Indies in the second ODI was marked by a subpar performance. The match saw 84 runs conceded by Nabi, the most expensive economy rate of the match. This led to concerns over choosing Nabi over Siraj. Fans and analysts questioned the decision. The West Indies crossed the 300-run threshold in the match. Nabi's high run conceded highlighted the challenges he faces.