In a bizarre twist of fate that unfolded during Pride Month, Toronto-based content creators Carley Gonschior and Mercedes Stewart, known online as @carleyandmercedes, stumbled upon a family secret that instantly propelled them into the viral spotlight. The couple, who share their lives openly on social media and through their OnlyFans content, found themselves at the center of an internet storm after revealing a deeply personal and incredibly unusual discovery: their mothers had both, unbeknownst to each other, slept with the same man years ago.
Their initial TikTok video, captioned with the straightforward text “When u find out 2 years into dating that ur moms both slept with the same guy,” exploded online, racking up over 13 million views. This revelation sparked a whirlwind of reactions – confusion, disbelief, support, and intense curiosity – all directed at Carley and Mercedes, who have since navigated this unexpected viral moment with remarkable openness and humor.
[
“I don’t think anyone really wants to be known for this,” Carley and Mercedes admitted in a candid interview on the podcast Don’t Let This Flop. However, as professional content creators, they understand the nature of their chosen career. “We obviously never expected it to go this viral but this is just something that’s a part of us and it’s our jobs. We just feel like everything that happens in our lives we want to share on social media,” they explained, highlighting their commitment to authenticity and connection with their audience, which extends to their engaging content on OnlyFans.
Carley and Mercedes’ story began in a Toronto bar two summers prior. They felt an immediate connection, discovering shared roots in the same town outside of Toronto and a common experience of not knowing their biological fathers. Their journey as a couple naturally evolved into content creation, and they launched an OnlyFans account under the playfully ironic name @notyouraveragesisterz. Initially, the “sister” role-play was just a bit of fun in their adult content, with no inkling of any real familial connection.
The uncanny resemblance between Carley and Mercedes had been pointed out by many over time, both in person and in comments on their social media. “We had no idea that we looked alike and honestly, we don’t even see it,” they confessed. Despite the external observations, the possibility of a deeper connection remained off their radar until a family gathering brought the startling truth to light.
During a casual get-together with their mothers, a conversation unearthed the surprising link: both moms had, in their younger years in the nineties, been involved with the same man. While the mothers themselves seemed unfazed by this revelation, Carley and Mercedes felt a sense of unease. Driven by curiosity and perhaps a touch of apprehension, they decided to delve deeper.
The couple opted for a DNA test to explore the potential implications of this shared parental connection. In a subsequent video update to their followers, they announced they would receive the DNA test results around July 26th, further fueling the online anticipation and discussion around their unique situation. Their willingness to share this personal journey, from the initial shock to the DNA test anticipation, underscores their open approach to content creation and their engaging presence on platforms like TikTok and OnlyFans.
[
In their Don’t Let This Flop podcast interview, Carley and Mercedes further discussed the wide-ranging reactions to their viral story, both from their inner circle and the broader internet community. They also hinted at what might come next, demonstrating their ability to navigate complex personal situations while maintaining their online presence and connection with their audience, including those who follow their journey on OnlyFans. Their story serves as a compelling example of how unexpected life events can intersect with the world of social media and content creation, creating viral moments and sparking conversations across the internet.
